top of page

Cough Assist vs. Tracheal Suctioning and Its Importance for Home Ventilation

Ventilating patients, especially in a home environment, is a complex task. A crucial component of ventilation is the effective clearance of the airways. This is where the Cough Assist comes into play. This device improves bronchial hygiene in patients with secretions in the airways and ineffective cough. A recent study has investigated the effects of the Cough Assist on airway clearance in mechanically ventilated patients.

Weinmann ACCUVAC Pro

Cough Assist vs. Tracheal Suctioning: A Study Analysis

The study published in the Indian Journal of Critical Care Medicine compared the physiological effects and secretion volume of mechanical insufflation-exsufflation (Cough Assist device) with isolated endotracheal suctioning in mechanically ventilated patients.

Methodology of the Study

The study was conducted as a randomized crossover study. Tracheal suctioning and mechanical insufflation-exsufflation were performed according to the recommendations of the American Association for Respiratory Care and with the Cough Assist device (Philips Respironics, CA-3000, USA).

Results of the Study

The study found that there is no significant difference in the amount of secretions suctioned when comparing a mechanical insufflator-exsufflator (Cough Assist device) with traditional tracheal suctioning. There were no significant differences in lung compliance, pulmonary resistance, mean arterial pressure, peripheral oxygen saturation, and secretion volume in both groups.

The Importance of Cough Assist for Home Ventilation

Despite the results of the study, which showed no significant improvement in airway clearance through the use of Cough Assist devices in mechanically ventilated patients, the use of Cough Assist devices, especially in home ventilation, has its advantages. They are easy to use and can make therapy more efficient and less burdensome for the patient.

Tracheal suctioning is an invasive process that carries a higher risk of infection. This risk is exacerbated by the fact that it significantly worsens the patient's "therapy comfort". In the home ventilation situation, where patients are often cared for by family members or caregivers without intensive medical training or experience, this can become a significant problem.

In contrast, the Cough Assist is a non-invasive device that facilitates airway clearance without increasing the risk of infection. It is easy to use and requires (after setting by professional staff) no special medical training, making it ideal for home ventilation. In addition, the Cough Assist can help reduce the burden on the patient by reducing the need for invasive procedures for airway clearance.

These factors were not considered in the study but are crucial for home ventilation. It is important that future studies consider these aspects to get a more complete picture of the benefits of the Cough Assist for home ventilation.

Innovative Solutions for Secretion Management

With innovative solutions like the BiWaze Cough, ventilated patients and their caregivers can benefit from effective and user-friendly support in airway clearance. The BiWaze Cough is a new and innovative solution for secretion management, raising the therapy standard with its dual blower system, user-friendly design, and other features like PAP on Pause (pause pressure).

Conclusion: The Future of Home Ventilation

Ventilation, especially home ventilation, is a complex process that requires effective airway clearance. While studies like the one mentioned above provide important insights into the effectiveness of devices like the BiWaze Cough, it is important to consider the individual needs and circumstances of each patient. With advancing technology and innovative solutions like the BiWaze Cough, we can hope to further improve the care and management of ventilated patients.


bottom of page